Feedback NEP/TIN Player Ratings

[Chris Website URL Visit Site 𝕏 fmcj10 Instagram fmcj10]

Roy Carroll: Earned himself a needless booking for disputing a foul on Liam Noble, but made a series of excellent saves to keep the score down. 7
 

Curtis Thompson: The right-back was solid if unspectacular. Tried to be creative going forward but found it tough going. 6
 

Louis Laing: The Forest defender will be kicking himself at being on the losing side for the first time since he arrived from the City
Ground on loan. 6
 

Haydn Hollis: Went close with a header in the first half and made a couple of excellent tackles when Swindon created great opportunities. 6
 

Blair Adams: Final ball just lacked that bit of quality at times, but no faulting his effort both defensively and offensively. 6
 

Garry Thompson: Toiled away, but found himself well marshalled by the Robins whenever he found himself in possession. 6
 

Gary Jones: Tough afternoon for the experienced midfielder against a midfield of pace and creativity. 6
 

Liam Noble: The midfielder saw a free-kick saved, but was targeted by Swindon off the ball perhaps trying to exploit his fiery temperament. Sent off in the second half. 6
 

Drissa Traore: Very comfortable on the ball, but just lacked a little creative vision in trying to open up the Swindon defence. 6
 

Stephen McLaughlin: Was always going to be a threat from delivering set-pieces and had a great duel with Nathan Byrne. 6
 

Jake Cassidy: Tried desperately to get into the game, but the lack of service was a problem for the on-loan Wolves forward. 6
 

Subs: Michael Petrasso (for Cassidy 46), Shaun Harrad (for Curtis Thompson 62), Ryan Hall (for Jones 69); not used: Smith, McKenzie, Cranston, Pilkington

I'll post mine below (I realize this is all opinionated but giving 6's seems a little idol to me)

They're having a laugh right? Thoughts?

[Chris Website URL Visit Site 𝕏 fmcj10 Instagram fmcj10]

• 01 Carroll - 7

• 15 C. Thompson 4 (Harrad - 62' 6)
• 34 Laing 6
• 06 Hollis 5
• 03 Adams 5
• 25 Traore 6.5
• 13 Jones 4 (Hall - 69' 4)
• 16 Noble 4
• 32 McLaughlin 4
• 11 Thompson 7
• 12 Cassidy 2 (Petrasso - 45' 5)

[liampie]

• 01 Carroll - 7

• 15 C. Thompson 2 (Harrad - 62' 4)

34 Laing 4

06 Hollis 3

03 Adams 5

25 Traore 6

13 Jones 3 (Hall - 69' 3)

16 Noble 2

32 McLaughlin 4

11 Thompson 6.5

12 Cassidy 0 (Petrasso - 45' 4)

[GrannyPie]

That bad ?@liampie

[Chris Website URL Visit Site 𝕏 fmcj10 Instagram fmcj10]

@GrannyPie that good for the NEP/TIN? I think they're trying too hard to please us NCFC fans.

[CliftonMagpie]

They always overrated players and certain ones dont even get the marks they deserve.

I stopped reading them years ago. Its all focused on red and white, not black and white!