Interesting, although contradictory, contributions from @theAnticlough and @Graham here. In a way I agree with both. JJ is a player who gets you out of your seat and has contributed to countless goals. Without him, it's quite possible we wouldn't be where we are today. I'm also in no doubt that he's good enough for L1. He's one of the last players I wanted to see leave, let alone to a potential rival. Yet the club shouldn't be sentimental. After winning promotion back to the league, we held on to players we, with hindsight, should have parted ways with. I believe it cost us back-to-back promotions. JJ offers flair and creativity, but isn't very strong defensively and perhaps the club thought it could get an upgrade. Hence him possibly being offered new terms as a squad player rather than the automatic starter he wanted to be. We've let go of quality players before and emerged stronger overall. If the new LWBs are a worthy replacement and the squad as a whole is improved and can compete at L1 level, we might have done the right thing here, as sad as it feels right now. I'm just glad that the uncertainty and the rumours have ended.