Can Notts and Others Make the Leap? A Look at League 2 Promotion Prospects

Notts have made no secret of their ambition to improve on last season’s mid-table finish and push for promotion this season. Finishing in the play-offs seems a very realistic target. However, it’s not going to be easy. Several clubs have similar aims and have recruited well in the hope of securing a place in League 1 come the end of the 2024/25 season. This isn’t a prediction as such but rather an analysis of the teams that have recruited well and will be hoping to push for promotion this coming season. (Yes, I’m too cautious to stick my neck out and predict who will get promoted!)

MK Dons, having finished 4th last season, will be many fans’ favourites to win the league next season. There could be some concerns given their poor showing in the play-offs, but over the course of a long season, with the talent they have in their team, I’d expect MK to do well. They’ve strengthened their defence with the signings of centre-backs Sam Sherring and Luke Offord. Both are 24 years of age but have considerable league experience. Sam, formerly of Northampton, won promotion to League 1 and was a key player in their team, while Luke was captain at Crewe, racking up over 150 appearances. Just like Notts, they have also acquired two players from Crawley. Liam Kelly and Lawrence Maguire were mainstays in the team last season and both featured in the side that beat MK in the play-offs. They’ve added experience too, with Tom Carroll, who played in the Premier League with Tottenham and Swansea, and was playing for Exeter in League 1 last season. The central midfielder impressed their fans in his 42 appearances and turned down their contract offer. Losing young forward Max Dean to Gent isn’t ideal, but replacing him with Salford’s Supporters’ Player of the Season, Callum Hendry, will have softened the blow. On paper, MK have had an extremely impressive summer, adding a lot of quality to what was already a strong squad. A top-three finish should be their aim.

It’s no secret Gillingham are financially well-backed and were one of the teams tipped for promotion last season, but they struggled for goals, scoring only 46 – the second-lowest in the division. So, this summer, it’s no surprise their recruitment has focused more on attacking players. Jack Nolan scored 17 goals for Accrington last season, and he’ll be hoping to continue that form for the Gills. Elliot Nevitt wasn’t far behind in the scoring charts, netting 16 times as he helped Crewe to a play-off final. Armani Little has joined from Wimbledon and should add some much-needed creative flair. Meanwhile, the direct and quick winger Arron Rowe has joined from Huddersfield after a solid season on loan at Crewe. Perhaps the most important new recruit, however, is head coach Mark Bonner. His last spell in League 2 was with Cambridge, and it ended in promotion to League 1, as well as finishing as the league’s top scorers. Given Gillingham had the 4th most touches in the opposition’s box last season, the addition of some proven goalscorers should result in more goals. They’ll be hoping the added firepower will get them closer to promotion this season.

Doncaster had an incredible finish to last season, winning 10 in a row and only losing 1 in 18, so for many, they were the favourites going into the play-offs. However, a defeat to Crewe meant they missed out on Wembley and face another season in League 2. Billy Sharp is the headline signing, rejoining his old club, but at the age of 38, he’ll need to be managed effectively to get the best from him. Harry Clifton is a smart signing; the former Grimsby Player of the Season will improve their central midfield options, and Joe Sbarra will add creative flair. Winger Jordan Gibson was surprisingly released by Carlisle after making 40 appearances in League 1 and scoring 9 goals. Doncaster have kept most of their side together from last season and have signed some talented players. Manager Grant McCann will be counting on continuing their good form into the new season, and they’d have no excuses if they don’t finish inside the top 7 again.

Swindon have high hopes for this campaign too. Their controversial owner, Clem Morfuni, has said, “The budget’s gone up. Our budget’s quite healthy this season, and you’ll see that reflected in the players we sign.” I’d agree – their summer recruitment has been encouraging. They’ve signed three centre-backs, with the headline signing being Grant Hall, who’s made over 150 appearances in the Championship, most notably for QPR. However, recent injuries have meant he’s struggled for game time, but if he can stay fit, he will be one of the best centre-backs in the league. Just as impressive is Will Wright, who was one of the stand-out centre-backs in League 2 last season. He’s equally adept on the ball as he is off it, so he will be a massive help in playing out from the back. Ryan Delaney, who turned down a contract offer from Newport, should provide good competition too. In Rosaire Longelo and Tunmise Sobowale, they’ve added two young wing-backs with experience of playing in League 1. In midfield, they’ve paid an undisclosed fee to sign Ollie Clarke, who was a key man in Mansfield’s promotion-winning side. And Harry Smith, the 6ft 5in striker who scored 11 times in a poor Sutton side, will provide a different and more direct attacking option. Swindon's fans have doubts over their owner, and ultimately what goes on behind the scenes seems to dictate a club’s fortunes. While those at the top might aim high, if the unsavoury relationship between fans and board continues, it will probably hinder the club’s progression.

Darren Moore will be expected to get Port Vale back into League 1 at the first time of asking. At the end of the 2023 season, he had just led Sheffield Wednesday back into the Championship, yet now in 2024, he finds himself in League 2. George Byers is their stand-out signing; the central midfielder has played his entire career in the Championship and League 1, and at the age of 28, it’s surprising he’s now dropped into League 2. You have to assume playing under Moore at Sheffield Wednesday was a key factor in this move. His potential midfield partner, Ryan Croasdale, was a player many Notts fans would’ve been pleased to see at Meadow Lane after helping Stockport win the League 2 title a few months ago. Jayden Stockley is also dropping back down into League 2. His last time playing at this level was with Exeter between 2017 and 2019, where he scored 36 goals in 66 games. He’s since been less prolific but decent nonetheless as he’s spent his time in the Championship and League 1. If they were concerned Stockley may not hit the heights, they’ve backed him up with two young promising forwards: Lorent Tolaj, who scored 19 goals in the National League for Aldershot, and Ruari Paton, who scored 17 in the Scottish Championship. The main concern for Vale would be bringing their disastrous form into next season, having only won twice in 2024. It might also take the signings time to gel, but if they do click, they should be a really impressive team.

Fleetwood has managed to recruit some good players, noticeably a trio of talented midfielders in Matty Virtue, Mark Helm, and Elliot Bonds. However, a number of good players have departed to stay in League 1. Clubs like Crewe and Wimbledon have found themselves in a similar situation, losing good players after a successful season and struggling to bring in quality replacements. Interestingly, Chesterfield are the current bookies’ favourites for the title, but I would be very surprised to see them top of the table come the end of the season. Their only strong additions have been Paddy Madden and centre-back Chey Dunkley, who featured regularly in League 1 for Shrewsbury. I think a play-off spot is a more realistic target. Some other notable transfers for teams hoping to improve on last season include the signing of Ben Woodburn by Salford. The former Liverpool player was described as one of the most gifted young players at the club and, at the age of 24, has even made 11 appearances for Wales. Bradford has added the talented attacking midfielder Antoni Sarcevic after his departure from Stockport, and Charlie Wyke could be a tip for top scorer. He’s been racking up goals for numerous League 1 clubs before re-signing for Carlisle, who will be hoping to bounce back after last season’s relegation.

The season’s start is nearly upon us, but only at the end of the season will we be able to see if the recruitment has paid off. The promotion fight could be a lot closer with well-backed teams like Stockport, Wrexham, and Mansfield all gone. Let’s just hope Notts, after a decent summer of recruitment, find themselves in the thick of the battle to get to League 1 too!

Click here to join in with the Pride of Nottingham's match discussion: Share your thoughts and opinions ahead of this weekend's opening League Two fixture against Tranmere Rovers.

Join in the debate and add your thoughts on the new away and third kit: do you like them? Have your say on this matter within the Pride of Nottingham community forum.