Joe McDonnell looks like a capable keeper, who looks like he's happy to be a backup which is what Neal Ardley might want. I hope fans will provide feedback on how he does, so that it gives me or other exile fans a better understanding.

From the games so far McDonnell has done ok but I much prefer slocombe in goal

joe had a bad time yesterday, it happens but i think he looks good enough to cover. i just think slocombe is a very solid keeper at this level and we look better with him.

Cant wait for slocombe to be back.

I am in a constant state of laughter with how fickle some fans are, those who want Ross back. Its beyond pathetic, many wanted him gone and are now starting on Joe because support isn't in some fans dictionary. I won't apologise, I will say it how I see it. Ross looked a decent prospect but the mans like a broken milk bottle under pressure, Joe is nothing more than a backup keeper who will have some bad games.

Who would I rather have? Neither, I want Sam back between the sticks ASAP.

He looks nothing more than a backup keeper, I don’t care about Ross Fitzsimons, he needed to go. I want to know when Sam Slocombe will return.