Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Pride of Nottingham (Notts County Community)

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Manager or Director of Football?

Topic summary unavailable for this older discussion

This topic falls outside the current Topic Summaries window because of its age, so a catch-up is not available here.

Subscribe to unlock enhanced topic summaries on eligible discussions while helping to support Pride of Nottingham and features like this.

Featured Replies

  • Author

This is my problem with the DOF/ HC model

The Director of Football is generally considered above a Head Coach in the organisational hierarchy with the head coach reporting to the DoF. The DoF oversees the entire sporting side, including player recruitment, squad planning, and strategic vision, while the head coach focuses on on-field performance and training. 

This has the potential for conflict & disagreement regarding football operations. We don't know what the circumstances of Roberto's reasons for leaving, but whether things were running smoothly behind the scenes is open to conjecture.

Players need to know that things are running smoothly at a club to play at their best. I just think that the old fashioned Manager / Player works best when it comes to hands on management & coaching, but I do respect the opinions of others who do have an alternative point of view.

Proud to be a supporter for 58 years & counting of the oldest professional football club in the World. COYP

Matchday Correspondent
Subscriber
Subscriber
  • Replies 33
  • Views 4.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • StarkMallard
    StarkMallard

    I'd prefer to see us hire an experienced DoF / recruitment head who knows how to put a squad together than give the job to our relatively inexperienced head coach. In principle there's no reason why a

  • Given our recruitment set-up is a tad different to the norm, I don’t think it would make sense to suddenly make the head coach totally responsible for recruitment and effectively merge the two roles.

  • Bit unfair on Traore @CliftonMagpie. He played well for his cameo against Fleetwood, just needs a goal and a run of games to show what he can do. Unfortunately or fortunately, we've changed our game p

23 hours ago, piedestrian said:

@gtownjohnno ,sorry but he's really proving an astute hire to Swansea.

To the point, I don't think we can really go back to a manager's manager role at Notts.

I think the mechanisms are just too different, plus as much as I've come to get used to MP, I wouldn't trust his judgement on new signings alone.

so astute he's leaving...

BBC Sport
No image preview

Richard Montague: Swansea City director of football set t...

Richard Montague left a similar role at League Two club Notts County to take up what is a key position at Swansea in February.

Notts seem to like having groups of people involved in talks about tactics, how the club runs and the results. So I suggest the club hires @Chris, @Piethagoram, @ARLukomski and KC from Twitter. With those four, I reckon recruitment would be smart and successful.

On a serious note, how hard would it be to have someone who checks all the player shortlists, sees who is a free agent, and talks through the best options for Notts. They could work out which players fit the budget and would make the squad stronger.

I don’t want a manager who just brings in his mates, or the owner picking players he thinks are great. That kind of thinking doesn’t help. I also don’t want to see the club take big risks like the £300,000 we spent on Izale McLeod. It feels like we’re seeing the same thing again with Mai Traore.

Oh oh oh ohhhhh, everywhere where we go, watching super County putting on a show!

image.png

@CliftonMagpie Thanks for the vote of confidence but Declan's ( @ARLukomski ) colleagues at Notts County Stats deserve a gateway into #Notts to deliver an opinion.

McLeods fee I think was around £115k .... Fact for the day Izale never scored an away goal for Notts

If you learn something from every game, there shall come a point in time, when you should never lose... Jimmy Sirrel

Match Scout

Bit unfair on Traore @CliftonMagpie. He played well for his cameo against Fleetwood, just needs a goal and a run of games to show what he can do. Unfortunately or fortunately, we've changed our game plan to accomodate a player like Jatta, which Traore isn't. I feel he's more of a poacher and technically stronger, similar to Langstaff than a Jatta style forward.

4 minutes ago, piedestrian said:

Bit unfair on Traore @CliftonMagpie. He played well for his cameo against Fleetwood, just needs a goal and a run of games to show what he can do.

Yes, I agree with you. My point is more about spending a large amount on one player when there are other parts of the team that could use that money more wisely.

Izale McLeod, to be fair, wasn’t as much of a flop as people said at the time. The problem was that we didn’t play to his strengths. Notts seemed to expect the striker to chase after the ball, rather than pass it to his feet or close enough for a quick burst.

Even so, the fees in both cases do seem like they could have been used better. It’s about making smart choices that help the whole squad, not just one position.

Oh oh oh ohhhhh, everywhere where we go, watching super County putting on a show!

image.png

26 minutes ago, CliftonMagpie said:

Notts seem to like having groups of people involved in talks about tactics, how the club runs and the results. So I suggest the club hires @Chris, @Piethagoram, @ARLukomski and KC from Twitter. With those four, I reckon recruitment would be smart and successful.

Not to be taken in the wrong context, but I don't think any supporter should hold any role close to their club where decisions could be based more on their heart than head. I also, wouldn't want to work in football.

I would probably fall asleep during discussions, not because of how long or boring they might be but my time of doing anything like this has long past.

Notts has a lot of collective minds, that are able to spot talent and if any wish to get involved in football, I would hope they find a path in via another clubs door because I would fear they might lose their passion for Notts if they were directly involved. I have done work in football, taking photographys for local non-league teams and had a stint where I help one with his online presence.

I much enjoyed them, then anything of the fan meetings or other involvements close to Notts that I have had.

chris-sig.webp

A field where dreams become reality.

3 hours ago, Wheelbarrow repair man said:

My Choice would be Neil Warnock. Yes I know there's lots of People on the Site will Disagree with me, but he does fit the necessary criteria and they'd be a Fair Bit Of Media Coverage For The Club.

With respect @Wheelbarrow repair man Warnock was a great man motivator. The "brains" behind Warnock was the late great Mick Jones ( a reminder it was Mick that found Grealish and McGregor for #Notts, not Warnock!

"Fair bit of media coverage for the Club" shouldn't come into it, it's all about finding the right person for the job

If you learn something from every game, there shall come a point in time, when you should never lose... Jimmy Sirrel

Match Scout

@Piethagoram . Neither Neil Warnock or Mick Jones was at the Club when Jack Grealish and Connor McGregor played for the Magpies, if I remember right. Shaun Derry and Greg Abbott were Head Coach and Assistant during Grealish and McGregor's time at the Lane.

1 hour ago, Wheelbarrow repair man said:

@Piethagoram . Neither Neil Warnock or Mick Jones was at the Club when Jack Grealish and Connor McGregor played for the Magpies, if I remember right. Shaun Derry and Greg Abbott were Head Coach and Assistant during Grealish and McGregor's time at the Lane.

Chris Kiwomya was in charge when they joined, with Mick Jones as his assistant. I think Jones was responsible for bringing Grealish in (there was some scepticism as we already had a teenage loanee in McGregor). Derry took over later that season to keep us up.

The duck that ate DangerousSausage

ryapor-moon-3311534_small.jpg

Community Leader
  • Author

Either Google AI is confused or something else is at play but just looked up who was the manager when Grealish played for Notts and this was the result.👇

"Shaun Derry wss the manager of Notts County when Jack Grealish played there on loan during the 2013-14 season. Grealish joined Notts County on a youth loan from Aston Villa in September 2013 and made his professional debut for the club under Derry's management". 

Source Google AI.

Proud to be a supporter for 58 years & counting of the oldest professional football club in the World. COYP

Matchday Correspondent
Subscriber
Subscriber

That's why you shouldn't rely on AI @Robbie! Kiwomya and Jones were in charge when Grealish and McGregor joined in August/September 2013. They were then sacked a couple of months into the season, with Derry joining in November 2013, but the loanees were both already first team regulars by then.

The duck that ate DangerousSausage

ryapor-moon-3311534_small.jpg

Community Leader
  • Author

I think the thread has drifted off topic.This is a reminder of the original question.

Do PON members think that the Director of Football should be replaced by an experienced League 2 Manager/ Head Coach type or just amalgamate the two roles of Head Coach and Director of Football into one?

Is it important that the Club has a Director of Football or not. Can a First Team Manager do both roles successfully at Notts?

Proud to be a supporter for 58 years & counting of the oldest professional football club in the World. COYP

Matchday Correspondent
Subscriber
Subscriber

As @DangerousSausage correctly says, Mick Jones as Kiwomya's assistant. Mick Jones brought in Grealish and McGregor. How do I know, Mick Jones told me.

If you learn something from every game, there shall come a point in time, when you should never lose... Jimmy Sirrel

Match Scout
  • Author

What isn't in doubt is that Grealish spent the vast majority of his loan time at Notts under Shaun Derry. Grealish had his loan period extended under Derry. It was unfortunate that Derry couldn't extend MacGregor's loan period too.

Proud to be a supporter for 58 years & counting of the oldest professional football club in the World. COYP

Matchday Correspondent
Subscriber
Subscriber

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.