- ⚡What are your thoughts on Jodi Jones, playing the attacking centre midfield role?🏃🏻 Would it offer him more protection?
- 👋🏻 Welcome the newest members of Pride of Nottingham! Drop by and say hello, it’s always great to see fresh faces joining the community. 🫱🏼🫲🏼
- The Pride of Nottingham Prediction League is back, round 6, is now available for your predictions
- Notts have signed tralist Keanan Bennetts, share your thoughts on this signing here.🤔
- 👀 Check out our activity stream to see the latest content as it happens live. Join in with the conversation on Pride of Nottingham.
- Got thoughts on Notts? Share them and help Pride of Nottingham hit its content target! 🏁
- Check out the latest Notts County academy news! 👇🏻
- Reply to and read discussions without leaving your screen. Check out the Pride of Nottingham 'Topic Feed', which brings you all the latest content from our community forum in one place.

Everything posted by Chris
-
Noisy Neighbours
I can see Notts winning this now, yet the tie hasn't impressed me to be honest - Yet I don't knock them but in an ideal world, a different team would have been nice. We have to make the most of the games given, though the JPT isn't a competition many take seriously. Bring on Mansfield again!
-
Stat Attack: Oxford United vs Notts County
I hope fans see another Stevenage/Huddersfield performance, I do think we can win but much for me will go down to whoever has the strongest midfield - of course, we could but then our defence lets us down. Let's hope this isn't the case today.
-
Oxford - Scouting Report
The Magpies will have to put the disappointment behind themselves, after their recent game against Mansfield. All focus must be on the task at hand, whilst of course pushing for all three points. Oxford United will most likely allow Notts to play, so it should make for an entertaining game within the lower tier. It’s important neither side sit back, as both teams are prone to making their own mistakes. Run down of their recent games. Saturday 8th August – Oxford 1 Crawley 1 Tuesday 11th August – Brentford 0 Oxford 4 (League Cup) Saturday 15th August – Luton 2 Oxford 2 The Players – Fact Sheet Highest Goal Scorers; Danny Hylton 2, Kemar Roofe 2, Johnny Mullins 1 and Liam Sercombe 1. Persistent Foulers; Alex MacDonald 2 Yellow Cards, Liam Sercombe 1 Yellow Card and Ryan Taylor 1 Yellow Card. The Key Players. Danny Hylton, Danny Rose, Kemar Roofe, Liam Sercombe and Jake Wright. Danny Hylton is a lively striker, who has the ability to get quick chances off and generally causes his opposition trouble. Danny Rose is Oxford's creative player, he likes to be direct and isn't afraid to get into challenges or avoid passes when he is being marked. Likewise, Kemar Roofe and Liam Sercombe like to be direct themselves, with a natural ability on the ball the pair team up well and offer United quite a lot of width. Jake Wright is their anchor within defence, he tries to keep the game simple but tackles well. Style of Play, Strengths, and Weaknesses. Oxford United appear to be your typical lower league team, they try to counter breaks after their opposition have thrown men forward. They’re patient and slow at building, yet can inject pace when the need is required. However, to a degree their approach is somewhat scrappy. The main strength is from their creative players, they look for alternative options when their game plan does not seem to work. They invite play onto themselves, so that they can then hit back with their own attacks and generally try to frustrate their opposition. With regards to weaknesses, for me it’s all about their scrappy play. Good teams will be able to flood their back line, which would put pressure onto themselves. Their keeper Sam Slocombe didn’t really impress me within their highlights, he seems to be a risk for me as he didn’t control his area well and when he came to making basic saves – He tended to drop the ball and generally created tension within his own defensive, which lead to Luton Town scoring against them. If Notts can penetrate through the centre of the box, allowing players to shoot from the edge of the box – Potential tap ins may occur, but crosses is another area whereby the Magpies can exploit.
-
Blair Adams on defending set pieces
It's not just set pieces, although that is what's punishing probably the most. It's the fact we fail to get to the second ball or try to win it back when we lose it. The Stevenage game, each player seemed focused on winning the ball back and getting it out of danger - not just that but also making use of it. If we could set the marking up, always making sure we have a touch of the ball - Things at the back will improve.
-
The Match Officials
Tuesday 18th August, Notts County travel to the Kassam Stadium to play Oxford United. Notts go into the game after losing our local derby against Mansfield 2-0. The U's come into the game having enjoyed their own cup success away from home against Brentford where they won 4-0, they also battled bravely against Luton Town to get a share of the points. Both teams will be eager to acquire the maximum points available, so that they kick start their season. The Match Officials for the game against Oxford United will be Rob Lewis, with his two assistants Richard Hulme and Nick Hobbis. The fourth official will be Timothy Wood. Due to the fact we are at the start of the season, it seems pointless to mention stats and so, I will include some details about the officials. Match Officials Referee; Rob Lewis From – Shropshire After looking at previous games whereby Rob Lewis has featured as a referee, it would suggest that he is a very adequate match official. In fact, last season he only issued 2 red cards and several match reports highlight his control and decisions through the game as being generally spot on. Assistant Referee; Richard Hulme From – Somerset Sadly yet again, there is very little information regarding Hulme as an assistant referee. Assistant Referee; Nick Hobbis From – West Midlands Nick was born in Birmingham and has spent numerous seasons officiating games as an assistant referee. Fourth Official; Timothy Wood From – Gloucestershire Do you have an opinion on the game? - Match Thread
-
"We can get better" says Rick Passmoor.
I've been saying since Wembley that the lady pies seem to have suffered from a lack of confidence. Yet this is more like it from the Notts manager, I felt disappointed by comments he made recently, as I feel you should always show ambition. There's nothing wrong with being honest, yet previous comments sounded like he had given up on this season and fans don't want to hear that.
-
League Two Preview
If we can score first, I think it will take some of the pressure from off ourselves which we currently seem to have on the shoulders. I am hoping to see more of Jenner, provided he starts. I do think that he isn't 100% and perhaps would be best to rely on another winger until he feels a little more up for it. The league table should change a fair bit, despite it being early days. Let's hope we can push up now.
-
League Two Preview
Another late Tuesday night is calling for football fans to encourage their sides onto victory; Pride of Nottingham is taking a look into the fixtures set to play-out on the 18th of August – as Notts prepare themselves for Oxford away from home. Meanwhile a host of teams will be hoping to lead the League Two table come the end of the night, as several top teams feature against difficult teams. Five teams start the night with perfect records, having all won their opening two games. * Important Game – ** Key Game Tuesday 18th August 2015 Accrington v Mansfield – Kick Off 7:45pm – Score Prediction (0-1) AFC Wimbledon v Cambridge – Kick Off 7:45pm – Score Prediction (1-2) Barnet v Northampton – Kick Off 7:45pm – Score Prediction (1-1) **Crawley v Portsmouth – Kick Off 7:45pm – Score Prediction (2-3) Dagenham & Redbridge v Exeter – Kick Off 7:45pm – Score Prediction (0-2) Hartlepool v Newport – Kick Off 7:45pm – Score Prediction (1-0) Leyton Orient v Stevenage – Kick Off 7:45pm – Score Prediction (2-2) *Luton v Bristol Rovers – Kick Off 7:45pm – Score Prediction (2-0) Morecambe v Wycombe – Kick Off 7:45pm – Score Prediction (0-1) *Oxford v Notts County – Kick Off 7:45pm – Score Prediction (0-1) **Plymouth v Carlisle – Kick Off 7:45pm – Score Prediction (2-1) York v Yeovil – Kick Off 7:45pm – Score Prediction (1-0) My Stand-Out Games Crawley v Portsmouth Luton v Bristol Rovers Plymouth v Carlisle Crawley will be hoping to get their first win of the season against promotion chasing Portsmouth, it will be potentially high scoring with the home side looking to capitalise on the return of out of favour striker Izale McLeod. The former Pompey star will be hoping to establish himself back within the Red Devils and encouraging a win may see him gain his wish. Despite predicting the score in favour of Portsmouth, I don’t think they will have it all plain sailing. At the start of the season Luton were tipped as one of the front-runners for promotion; however, their League Two campaign has been nothing but easy. Whilst Bristol Rovers will be hoping for back to back wins on the road after beating Yeovil Town 1-0. Plymouth Argyle will have a tough home game against Carlisle, as both sides will be hoping to avoid defeat. On paper, advantage seems to favour the home side who are in some decent form but have been struggling to iron out defensive woe’s, which has prevented them from retraining a perfect start to the season. Carlisle has the ability to push sides, which they will be hoping to make the most of on Tuesday. Thoughts on Oxford United vs. Notts County Despite the performance strung together at home on Friday night, I think Notts will be eager to make amends and will no doubt be a very good side away from home. Notts will have problems within their squad selection and potentially will lead a completely new line-up at the front, with Jon Stead likely to miss the game. Jimmy Spencer is most likely to start, with the issues continuing at the back due to key players being missing. Oxford has collected two very hard fought draws, with them highlighting their ability to score in previous games. Comparing the sides head to head, Notts narrowly lead with 9 wins but also share 9 draws, whilst Oxford have won 8 of the ties themselves. Much like the Stevenage game, I suspect the difference will be down to who scores first and yet, if the Magpies show a little bit of their cup spirit away from home against Huddersfield Town. Then perhaps I cannot write them off so easily, if Oxford United do open the account within our game first. Let’s hope it proves to be a bright display and no matter what, both sets of fans go home happy and entertained.
-
Moniz calls for improvement in attack
I am not sure a single striker at home will work, away from home it seems fine but we just don't create enough chances at Meadow Lane to warrant it. I really hope we start to see a partnership form, either give Campbell a chance or look to use the 100k we tried to sign McLeod with. No doubt we need to see more upfront and it terms of procession at home. That said, not every game will be like Mansfield. COYPs!!!
-
Prediction League Champions
Past Winners - PON Prediction League 2013/14 - @Chris - 154 Points 2014/15 - @super_ram and @Fan of Big Tone - 179 Points 2015/16 - @super_ram - 184 Points 2016/17 - @weymouthPIE - 208 Points 2017/18 - @weymouthPIE and @DangerousSausage - 184 points 2018/19 - @ARLukomski - 205 points (runner up @GrannyPie). 2019/20 - @ARLukomski - 214 points (runner up @Dan) 2020/21 - @ARLukomski - 233 points (runner up @Dripsey3) 2021/22 - @Dripsey3 - 259 points (runner up @Dan) 2022/23 - @ARLukomski - 243 points (runner up @Dripsey3) 2023/24 - @william1984 - 106 points (runner up @super_ram) 2024/25 - @super_ram - 294 points (runner up @ARLukomski)
-
League Two Round-Up
I was hoping to be able say Notts had remained undefeated but fair play to Mansfield, it's still hard to accept but we move on. Thanks for the round-up.
-
Notts brutally brought back to earth by rampant Stags
I'd have taken Jenner off at half time, he looks unfit and very sluggish. That said, I don't blame anyone for the defeat, simply Mansfield wanted it better than us. They quickly stamped their mark on the game, both in possession and within their tactics. It wasn't pretty at times for Stags, some of the things they did, really frustrated me but as I have said in many things - It was for Notts to overcome it. They didn't and so the rightful team won the game, however much I'd like it to have been Notts. We simple wasn't good enough and created very little. I am sure we will get better results within our next two games, Oxford is one whereby the squad need to put in that performance.
-
Site & Community Blog Updates
We have FIVE new features for folks to read. Many thanks to @super_ram for his help with the Liam Noble piece. Liam Noble repays Alan Smith's Experience - Here Mansfield Town - Opposition View | Thanks @Dan - Here League Two News - Here Mansfield Town - Scouting Report - Here The Build-Up - Here A lot of hard work here folks, please be sure to read, like, share and comment. You Pies!
-
The Build-Up
All is to play for today with the local derby being moved forward from its original schedule due to our neighbours game against Rotherham United. The game is likely to start off lively, with both teams having the chance to sit top of the League Two table. Mansfield come into the game with a draw and a loss in the League Cup against Championship side Sheffield Wednesday. On the other hand Notts have started very brightly after the end to their pre-season, on paper the Magpies will also be the favourites. Key Fixtures Friday 14th August 2015 Notts County v Mansfield Saturday 15th August 2015 Barnet v Wycombe Plymouth v Portsmouth Prediction Mansfield Town cannot be written off for their start so far within the 2015/16 campaign, it’s early in the season and teams are still finding their feet after assembling their new looking squad. The Stags have made some decent signings for the League Two level and will be fired up for the local derby game between us. I see the game ending 3-1 in our favour! C’mon You Pies!!! Match Odds Notts County to win 21/20 – Draw 12/5 – Mansfield Town to win 5/2 Head to Head Notts County – If Notts manage to pick up their second win of the season, it would see them move top of the League Two table temporarily. A draw would also have the same temporary effect, with the potential of ending up anywhere from 5th to 12th in my opinion. A loss would see us drop to around the upper half/mid table. Mansfield Town – A win for the Stags would see them move top of the division temporarily, allowing them to safely secure a upper half place. A draw would see them remain around the mid table and perhaps even drop towards the lower half, as will losing. Key Man Notts County; Stanley Aborah – He’s been a breath of fresh air since arriving and his presence allows Notts to play in a way which allows our advancing players more space to go forward themselves. He offers a mix of creativity, which watching his passing ability and trickery will be key to breaking down Mansfield. Mansfield Town; Craig Westcarr – The thorn in any side he features for against Notts, his ability to read the game and elude defenders will make him the Stags main threat with doubts hanging over Matt Green. League Table The current table shows 9 sides starting off quite healthy, with Portsmouth, Notts County and Plymouth Argyle all being tipped for promotion by the majority of bookies. After today’s results, the league won’t look too much different until the games set to face off on Saturday take place. It’s there I imagine the table will look quite different, with perhaps sides like Luton Town picking up maximum points and advancing up the table. Notts could go top as already mentioned, the same applies for Mansfield and this is another reason why the game between the two is paramount to both sides. There’s not a great deal in which I can mention right now, I don’t expect the leading pack to form until at least 7-9 games into the season. Yet, I do feel Notts have started brightly enough to warrant their odds for promotion and after making 18 signings so far, it shows just how much work has been made behind the scenes to start the season off so brightly. I think after Saturday, if my prediction is correct, Notts will find themselves around 2nd or 3rd which would be a fantastic position to push on from.
-
Mansfield - Scouting Report
The Magpies host Mansfield at Meadow Lane later today, the fixture is one which both sets of fans have been looking forward to and it should be an action packed game, with Stag fans flooding down to the ground to support their team. Mansfield will be looking to claim their first victory of the 2015/16 season, whilst also trying to protect their current undefeated record. With only one game in, the Stags will be required to find the determination to bring out the best of their play. Whilst, Notts must continue with their impressive form within this local derby. Run down of their recent games. Saturday 8th August – Mansfield Town 1 Carlisle United 1 Tuesday 11th August – Sheffield Wednesday 4 Mansfield Town 1 The Players – Fact Sheet. Highest Goal Scorers; Ryan Tafazolli 1, and Malvind Benning 1 Persistent Foulers; Adam Chapman 1 Yellow Card. The Key Players. Matt Green (if fit), along with former Magpie players Craig Westcarr and Kristian Pearce. There's doubts over Green's chances to start the game against Notts, however he is a very mobile striker who can stride into play and literally create chances, with the natural ability to finish. Mansfield have a fairly experienced squad, balanced out with ambitious signings and a core of physical players, with grit for the lower league. Adam Chapman is another player in which Notts should be aware of, however I left him out of the key players because of his inconsistency. Craig Westcarr requires no introduction, he is a player who can drift in and out of games. His ability to read movement, the game and of course a certain level of luck has made him a dangerous asset for whoever he features for. If Kristian Pearce plays to his potential, he will be the rock within the Stags defence. However, it is notable that Mansfield do possess other players of similar ability. Facing up against your former club usually brings the best out of players and I genuinely feel Pearce will be a player advancing Magpies must be aware of. Style of Play, Strengths, and Weaknesses. Adam Murray has impressed me with the amount of business and quality in which Mansfield have introduced to their ranks, it leaves questions to if they do require additional strength, but they have assembled a decent side for this division. They're an attacking side which shows no fear of going forward, but are prone to being a little physical to say the least. Mansfield haven't started off that badly considering, I feel the current results are down to players getting used to each other and although they took the lead against Carlisle, they didn't threaten them enough in my opinion. They like to lump the ball forward, making sure that teams have to match their physical attributes in order to find more time on the ball. Naturally, they attack via the flanks but also through the centre the park. The Stags main strengths come from their ability to get forward, whilst the key figures offer strength allowing them to avoid being push overs. Free flowing, fast paced football seems to bring pressure to the Mansfield defence and I have noticed the prone mistakes at the back from set pieces like corner kicks. Notts will have to use all their experience to avoid altercations, as Mansfield will no doubt attempt to rough up play, but if Notts keep the ball down, move quickly I feel this will be far too much for an newish assembled Stag side.
-
League Two News
I am pleased to see this back, as will the fan who asked if it would be coming back. Terry Butcher has a tough time with Newport, they have slashed their budget but if there's anyone who can inspire a side to stay up - It is him. Keith Curle's comments made me chuckle a little. Yet you should have mentioned Izale at Crawley, as it would seem they now either want to keep him or attract further interest from other clubs.
-
Mansfield Town - View
Thanks for taking the time to do this Dan! Much appreciated mate.
-
Mansfield Town - View
The upcoming local derby between Notts County and Mansfield Town has been labelled by magpies boss Ricardo Moniz as having “No difference between Arsenal and Spurs” and in fact mentioned “This club is also big”. Notts County have the foundation of having impressive performances under their belt, whilst Mansfield are yet to win within the 2015-16 season. Pride of Nottingham has taken the time to put several questions to one of the most recognizable match day photographers Dan Westwell. Firstly, could you please tell prideofnottingham.co.uk a little about yourself, such as how long you've been a Stags fan? I've been a Stags fan for 30 years, since I moved up here from Peterborough when I was 11. I wanted to support my local team and that's where it started. My first game was against the Canadian national team, we won 3-0! At the end of that season we went to Wembley in the Freight Rover Trophy and beat the favourites Bristol City on penalties who had Keith Curle and David Moyes playing for them. I thought I'd picked a winning team here but then the past 29 years have been a bit barren lol. What are stand-out moments from last season and how have things changed within the pre-season? There are no stand out moments from last season as it was a disaster. Had there not been 2 worse teams than us we would've gone back to that hell-hole again. We've got a lot to thank Tranmere & Cheltenham for. This season can't be as bad as that (we hope!). Adam Murray has signed some good players and there was a lot of positivity surrounding the club in the summer, a bit like at Notts, we just need to see how these players gel & then try and find a winning formula as I can't remember the last time we did win a game. Are you optimisic about your season ahead and what do you think of the squad assembled by Adam Murray? Yes I am, if you can't be optimistic in August when can you be!? The squad is very impressive, he's mixed it up well with some old heads, some new heads and some youth, so if he can get the blend right then we'll have a good season. Do you think having players like Craig Westcarr and Kristian Pearce will help you against Notts? I hope so. I was at the Forest game in the cup when Westcarr scored for Notts and he ran along the main stand celebrating in front of the Forest fans. I don't think he would disrespect Notts like that, but if he does I'll be happy as it means he's scored! Who do you think will the win the League Two title? More importantly where will Mansfield and Notts finish in your opinion? I think you can't look beyond Portsmouth & Luton really, but I've had an outside bet on Cambridge as I think they've assembled a good team. Having said that, Notts have been really impressive in the 2 games I've seen so far this season and if they carry this on, then they will win the league. I would love us both to go up, that would be awesome, especially if Forest got relegated! If I was forced to pick league positions I would go Notts 3rd and us 10th which I would take for sure with how we were last season. As the clubs official away day photographer, does it make it more interesting to cover these types of local derby games? It does at Field Mill because obviously I'm there doing the game for Notts yet it's at my 2nd home, so there's a strange feeling about it because I want both teams to win. Personally I want Stags to win because they are my team, but professionally I want Notts to win because it makes my photos better, if you can understand that? Like the pre season game last year when we hammered you ;-) the photos I was sending in were of fans looking fed up and not much action (especially goal action) so the pics weren't very good from a Notts angle (although my Stags mates loved them lol). As for this game, I would've been going as a freelance not being paid and would just sit in one place and see what happened, but now I am doing it for the local Mansfield paper (CHAD) so I will be doing the Stags attack & Stags fans rather than anything Notts as the home photographer will be doing that. What line-up would you feature against the Magpies? Who will be your key men? Matt Green, if he is fit would be our main threat I would say. But you never know if Westcarr & Pearce play then you could have the curse of the returning player. I wouldn't like to guess at our line up as I don't think even Adam Murray knows what team he will pick. Lastly, what do you think the score and scorers will be? If you'd asked me this on Monday I would've gone for a Stags win. But having seen what Notts did to Huddersfield last night I am actually pretty damn scared of what could happen to us. I wouldn't be shocked if Notts tanked us 4-0! We just have to hope that Notts continue their ill discipline and get an early sending off to give us a chance, but then they showed against Huddersfield that they can still see a game out with 10 men, away, at a Championship team. I just hope our good record against Notts helps us out, otherwise we could be in trouble. If you offered me a draw now I'd take it, a nice 2-2 like one of our favourite games when Iyseden Christie equalised 40 yards offside ;-) Pride of Nottingham would like to thank Dan Westwell for taking the time to answer our questions, we wish him all the very best with his recent fund-raising efforts and fingers crossed he brings Notts the luck tonight! No, good luck Mansfield in this new season.
-
Liam Noble repays Alan Smith's experience
I said this the other day, it's good he gave credit to Alan Smith but I don't think he's giving himself credit for what he's achieved to date. Last season he scored some very important goals and there's no doubt in my mind that he's improving but for me, it's down to his own attitude to apply what he's being told. Also, it highlights the additional experience in which Smith brings to the ranks at Meadow Lane. I hope he continues because he's the type of this club needs, I said this after all his disciplinary issues and when some wanted rid, I couldn't see us losing his potential.
-
Views from Across the Pond
Quite eerie how you are spot on with this mate! Always a fun and enjoyable read, as it's good to know what a fan leaving a way from Notts thinks. We'll get you back one day!
-
Stat Attack: Notts County vs. Mansfield Town
I'm still confident about the game despite the injury rumours, I think Spencer can come in but it's nice to have this game at this stage. Any other day, it may have killed things but Friday is pretty decent and hopefully we get a few down to the lane. Mansfield should bring a decent amount in terms of numbers.
-
Adam Murray Hypes Up Local Derby
I respect the comments he's making because if I supported Mansfield, I would want them to come here and try to get something. Just because on paper we have a better squad, won't mean we have won it and it's really for us to prove ourselves, not Mansfield. Right now many are expecting an high scoring game, in fact I think it's likely to see four goals scored. Yet, chances are the game will be a hard fought contest.
-
Site & Community Blog Updates
There's two new features here folks - Link By popular demand we return with 'League Round-Up' and 'The Match Officials', tomorrow will see the publication of the 'Scouting Report', Views from across the Pond by @Canadian and the 'Stat Attack'. Please do have a read and comment if you can.
-
The Match Officials
Friday 14th August, Meadow Lane play hosts to local rivals Mansfield Town. The Stags have started the season off by clinching a draw at Field Mill to travelling Carlisle United. The final score finished 1-1, Benning having opened the account for Mansfield. The Owls recently beat them 4-1 away from home in League Cup, yet the performances have left many questions for their own supporters. With Friday now quickly approaching, we here at Pride of Nottingham will share who the match officials are. The Match Officials for the game against Mansfield Town will be Tim Robinson, with his two assistants Jason Whiteley and Paul Hodskinson. The fourth official will be David Benton. Due to the fact we are at the start of the season, it seems pointless to mention stats and so, I will include some details about the officials. Match Officials Referee; Tim Robinson From – West Sussex Tim's record seems to suggest that he can be quite trigger happy with his cards, mostly which are yellow. However, he was promoted to the rank of level 1 as a match official back in the summer of 2012. He has a wealth of experience within the lower leagues, which tends to suggest he isn't that bad at controlling games but all will tell as to how he handles a local derby between two fierce rivals. Assistant Referee; Jason Whiteley From – West Yorkshire Jason is a assistant referee which all Notts County fans should be familiar with by now, last season he featured a few times within our 'Match Official' features and it leaves questions to ask about his ability from the sidelines. Assistant Referee; Paul Hodkinson From – Lancashire Unfortunately there isn't much information on Paul, yet as stated above he comes from Lancashire and has officiated games mostly within the Conference and Non League divisions. Fourth Official; David Benton From – South Yorkshire Do you have an opinion on the game? - Match Thread
-
League Two Preview
Oh for sure Liam, it's all open now. I mean just look at Cambridge but even now, there's some interesting fixtures which aren't consider key games but I still think they're important but you are right, currently teams are finding their consistency. Notts have impressed, Moniz and the lads have done incredibly well. Thanks for the comments everyone, nice to see such an eager response so early on!