Comment on the Richard Montague interview here
Who should be recruited in January? Read this excellent recruitment doc from member ARLukomski
PoN member McPie asks have we progressed under Martin Paterson? Join the conversation here.
PoN member theAnticlough poses a new set of questions about the team, click here.
Notts confirm Belshaw signing
👋🏻 Welcome the newest members of Pride of Nottingham! Drop by and say hello, it’s always great to see fresh faces joining the community. 🫱🏼‍🫲🏼
👀 Check out our activity stream to see the latest content as it happens live. Join in with the conversation on Pride of Nottingham.
Got thoughts on Notts? Share them and help Pride of Nottingham hit its content target! 🏁
Reply to and read discussions without leaving your screen. Check out the Pride of Nottingham 'Topic Feed', which brings you all the latest content from our community forum in one place.

Roy or Bart?

Topic summary unavailable for this older discussion

This topic falls outside the current Topic Summaries window because of its age, so a catch-up is not available here.

Subscribe to unlock enhanced topic summaries on eligible discussions while helping to support Pride of Nottingham and features like this.

View subscriptions

1. Which do you prefer?
- Roy
  
  78%
  
  11
- Bart
  
  21%
  
  3

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Chris

Administrators

Joined:
26/03/11
Age:
39

Location: Nottingham
BlueSky: fmchris10.bsky.social
𝕏: fmcj10

Chris's Rank Progress

Current Rank

Lv. 17

View All 20 Badges

Rare
Rare
Rare
Rare
Rare

October 2, 201412 yr

Author

#16

I've voted for Bart purely for the long term prospects, Roy is a great keeper but getting on a bit now.

I wish he would stop the blatant time wasting tactics as well, I pay to watch a game of football not to see Roy tie up his gloves for the umpteenth time.

I see no reason why Roy can't play until he's 40, I am very hopeful he can retain his fitness and ability to manage that. I quite fancy him being the keeper who manages to help gain us promotion. Bart is a great keeper, certainly too good for the bench.

He he... A lot of keepers time waste, I know a lot worse. Roy takes the sting out of games by doing this, he's very good at knowing when he can and can't time waste. Bart used to do it, yet he was rather obvious and the majority of cards shown as a direct result. Only keeper in the last 5 years I've seen keen to get on with play is young Fabs.

A field where dreams become reality.

Replies 21
Views 2.5k
Created 12 yr12 yr
Last Reply 12 yr12 yr

themightymagpies

Members

746 posts
12 Badges
1.5k Reputation

Joined:
02/10/14
Age:

themightymagpies's Rank Progress

Current Rank

Lv. 12

Next Rank

7430 / 9100

View All 12 Badges

October 2, 201412 yr

#17

Bart is not in Roy's shadows, any other signing might have been. I voted for Roy, he screams "class" at this level.

Super_Danny_Allsopp

Members

2.7k posts
15 Badges
2.7k Reputation
91 Days won

Joined:
07/08/13
Age:

Super_Danny_Allsopp's Rank Progress

Current Rank

Lv. 14

Next Rank

18698 / 20000

View All 15 Badges

Rare
Rare

October 9, 201412 yr

#18

Roy the better keeper, but if Bart would have stuck around he could have been our No.1 for a while.

BromPie

Members

1.5k posts
19 Badges
3.3k Reputation
5 Days won

Joined:
07/10/14
Age:

Location: Bromley

BromPie's Rank Progress

Current Rank

Lv. 14

Next Rank

15079 / 20000

View All 19 Badges

Rare
Rare

October 9, 201412 yr

#19

I voted Bart, no keeper does or did what he had during his time.

PTID1862

Members

Joined:
02/11/13
Age:

Location: Cumbria

PTID1862's Rank Progress

Current Rank

Lv. 15

Next Rank

23366 / 30000

View All 9 Badges

Rare

October 10, 201412 yr

#20

A difficult choice

Roy has been a fantastic keeper and played for some top sides, you do not get that opportunity unless you are right on top of your game, there are the odd exception of course Massimo Taibi, crikey even thinking about him gave me the willy's... how the hell did he get a wage out of Man U.

Bart, young, full of promise, but has now gone sideways, moving on to a higher club is only beneficial if you are playing games... no game time will mean his reactions will diminish.

We currently have the joint best defensive record in the football league, Roy takes his share of the credit for this... and I believe he may will end up taking not only the pot for Bargain of the season... signing of the season... but also player of the season.