Feedback Best Signings [Loans Included]

[Chris Website URL Visit Site 𝕏 fmcj10 Instagram fmcj10]

So, who's bee the best signings for you?

Permanent Signings;

Best -
Worst -

Loan Signings;

Best -
Worst -

Let's see who says what, if you want to add why you decided the players you picked feel free. I will wait until there's been a few posts but I have already done it.

[liampie]

Permanent Signings;

Best - carroll
Worst - smith

Loan Signings;

Best - laing
Worst - that santos

[CliftonMagpie]

Permanent Signings;

Best - Gary Jones

Worst - Shaun Newton

Loan Signings;

Best - Louis Laing

Worst - Adam Dawson <-- Just useless

[upthepies]

Permanent Signings;

Best - Roy Carrol, without him just like with Bartoz, we would be down and confirmed now.
Worst - Shaun Harrad, what a pointless signing but hardly his fault!

Loan Signings;

Best - Louis Laing, fantastic defender who got the best out of his partners (including Haydn Hollis).
Worst - The Thomas lad from Derby, I did not rate him.

[Feral Fox]

Best Gary Jones. The man is a warrior. Take note Neil Bishop.

Worst. Alan Smith. What a let down. Donkey.

Loans.

Best Zeli I or Laing. Both good players.

Worst. Lots of them . We've had our fair share of time wasters under Derry. Dawson probably.

[MuddyPatchPie]

Permanent Signings;

Best - Carroll

Worst - Whitehouse

Loan Signings;

Best - Laing

Worst - Lita

[allardyces tash]

Permanent Signings;

Best - Garry Thompson, without his goals we would have struggled and I cannot think of one which was not class.
Worst - William Hayhurst, one good game and nothing since. I hope Muniz can get more out of him but he has been very poor to say we paid for him. We did right?

Loan Signings;

Best - Paddy McCourt, ball greedy but a man of his class makes all the difference and if we did not have him. We would have been struggling far more!
Worst - Santos no question.

[eighteensixtytwo]

Best - Roy Carroll
Worst - Alan Smith

Loan Signings;

Best - Louis Laing
Worst - Leroy Lita

[Pies4u]

Best signings - close call but, probably, Carroll ........ Or Jones!

Worst - Whitehouse, Keane, Hayhurst, Smith. All completely useless.

Loans;

Best - Laing, closely followed by Williams.

Worst - most of the rest but, particularly utter rubbish like Santos, Thomas, White, Dawson - the list is endless. Utter tripe, with very few exceptions bar the 2 mentioned above & Burke. Lita is almost in a class of his own as being particularly disgraceful, given his background and experience.

[lambleypie]

Permanent Signings;

Best - Jimmy Spencer, seriously his return has been like a new signing. Roy Carroll or Gary Jones.
Worst - I have been disappointed with Nicky Wroe.

Loan Signings;

Best - Zeli Ismail
Worst - Santos

[NCRichie]

Best - Roy Carroll
Worst - Shaun Harrad

Loan Signings;

Best - I agree with Zeli Ismail or Louis Laing
Worst - Adam Dawson is a great punt.

[AmericanPie]

Permanent Signings;

Best - Jones or Noble

Worst - Newton

Loan Signings;

Best - Laing

Worst - ?